Jump to content
Aldon

Which Tractor should I keep if I can only keep 1

Which Tractor would be your choice as a long term worker. For ease of use, ease of maintenance and flexibility.  

61 members have voted

This poll is closed to new votes
  1. 1. Tractor choices - I have 2 stage blower, 48 inch deck, 60 inch deck and if I keep tractors with 3 point, then I have a GT14 style Tiller and Sickle bar(Project) ,

    • 314 H with gear reduction steering. Has 520 hours on the meter.
      16
    • GT16 (Restomod) GT14 restored with K341.
      8
    • C160 8 speed - Restored by Jeff/Fireman 9 hours on it since restore.
      27
    • GT22-8 Still in R&D alpha/beta state of build. 22HP predator, 8 speed, set up for independent 3 point.
      3
    • 1956 Rj35 with Clinton - Totally restored
      5
    • 1956 RJ35 3/4 restored,
      2

  • Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.
  • Poll closed on 02/09/2018 at 04:59 AM

Recommended Posts

 
 
WVHillbilly520H

Aldon, I believe the 314 would serve you well where ever you wind up with more support for parts if ever needed, to me it seems the most universal for attachments/implements as well, not saying the C-160-8 wouldn't be a close 2cd as the others and the C are more show rigs in my eyes, Jeff.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Big_Red_Fred

My Friend ericj in York Pa Would agree on the 314 decision to & i also, That's a do it all set of American steel ! Tho id take the C along for back-up

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Sarge

It's a tough decision and a shame you have to down-size - I'd have a very hard time doing that myself despite being quite limited on storage space.

 

I'd put a few things in consideration - newer, better designed engines with pressure lube versus splash lube. Parts availability (although we have such a network of parts available) and the most versatile model capable of whatever task is needed. With those in mind it's pretty tough with those models, but I'd keep that GT14 the most just due to being so rugged and heavy. A re-power later , if needed is not to hard and diesel options are something to consider despite the cost. Taken care of, it should outlive you easily and is capable of some very heavy work without a sweat. That said, the C-160 is so hard to beat for versatility and rugged simplicity, no wonder they are highly sought in both manual and hyrdo versions.

 

Good luck, I'd have a tough time parting with any of them.

 

Sarge

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Tankman
19 minutes ago, Sarge said:

Good luck, I'd have a tough time parting with any of them.

 

Sarge

:text-yeahthat: Agree 100% with Sarge. Think I would shed a few tears parting with any of your wonderfully kept Stallions.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
elcamino/wheelhorse

I would keep the C-160-8 , if you sell the others to Forum members I am sure they would let you visit the tractors when you come back East for a visit.

  • Like 6
  • Excellent 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
leeave96

IMHO, you should keep two tractors.  The hydro 314 and the C160 8 speed.  This gives you redundancy, commonality between implements and you’ve got both hydro and gear drive flavors covered.  IMHO, the perfect 2 tractor plan for the user and/or collector with limited space.

  • Like 7
  • Excellent 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
ebinmaine
2 minutes ago, leeave96 said:

IMHO, you should keep two tractors.  The hydro 314 and the C160 8 speed.  This gives you redundancy, commonality between implements and you’ve got both hydro and gear drive flavors covered.  IMHO, the perfect 2 tractor plan for the user and/or collector with limited space.

 

^^^^^

Got a point or two worth thought there.

 

I'd go with the C160 but I was torn between that and the 314H.

 

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
wallfish

Voted C-160 but that G-16 looks tastey too. 

  • Like 4
  • Excellent 1
  • Haha 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
pfrederi
15 minutes ago, ebinmaine said:

 

^^^^^

Got a point or two worth thought there.

 

I'd go with the C160 but I was torn between that and the 314H.

 

 

Redundancy is nice and you don't have to switch implements as often.  The tiller is a nice tool but how often do you use it (and the tines look a bit worn).  The GT 14 is a beast ...but an older beast and is less flexible in terms of implements....

 

One last thought.  as you age getting on and off the tractors gets less easy... Which one is easier for you.  One reason I love my Lawn ranger as a chore tractor easy on easy off...

  • Like 6
  • Excellent 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
JERSEYHAWG /  Glenn

Aldon, best of luck in deciding. I am evebtually moving only 4 miles. But to a way way smaller property. Frankly, I miss some of the machines I got rid of. They were hard to find and a few unique. I had 8 tractors, now down to 3. Right after the winter the 416-8 sadly will go. And just when I had it done, complete. It just sux sometimes. BUT, what the future holds is known to no one. Best of luck. My 854 with decks and blade is my keeper, AND MAYBE the C-175.   Decisions decisions.

 

Glenn

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Racinbob

If you are determined to scale back to just one I'm with the C-160 all the way. The nearly bullet proof K-series and I feel the mid 70's were the very best years for Wheel Horse. :)

  • Like 4
  • Excellent 3
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
ztnoo

Well...........gee...........what does a guy really say???, especially with all the toil and hard work you have been through with most of these tractors.
I'd say it almost equates to having 6 children and having to decide which five to leave behind with family members because you realistically know you can't feed all six where you are going......and on top of that, knowing you may never see them again.
That's a somewhat bogus analogy though because tractors are merely machines that work and do specific chores for us. They aren't our flesh and blood. They don't need to be fed and clothed and loved like we care for a child or children.
Nevertheless, there always is somewhat of an emotional attachment to these mechanical creatures. I think the more of them one acquires, the more deeply rooted that attachment becomes, logical or not.

I'm fortunate in that way in that all I've ever had is one tractor........the first year model 1-7441 GT 14. So, from that perspective, if I were you, I would naturally be partial to retaining your superb GT 16 Restomod..........which I believe was your first major Wheel Horse project. If I were you, I believe it would be hardest for me to part with this tractor. You probably have more mechanical experience with the GT model than any other. Of course, knowing your intellect and observational skills, you could easily become an expert with any of these other models of Wheel Horses as you are with the GT 14 beasts. So, perhaps that argument is negated.
By the same token its hard to argue with the other contributor's choices of either the 314 or the C160............or the the argument for retaining two with interchangeable implements.
I suggest you begin by choosing to sell the models with the least emotional attachment and the least utility based on where you end up moving......i.e where you might go could dictate what your needs will be. Your needs in Idaho, would likely be drastically different than say North Carolina, Indiana, Missouri, or New Mexico/Arizona.
Then finally.... the incomparable, remarkable, and as yet unfinished GT22-8. I'm left speechless when I think of you parting with that brilliant creation.

Life is full of choices, and as we age our goals and needs also change, especially if our working careers involved fairly frequent, not necessarily desired moves.
Start with the least important emotionally to you and evaluate each as to utility based on what you know at this point in time.
I have the impression you don't have to clean house tomorrow and wash your hands of it all by next weekend, so be cautious, take your time, and make a decision based your best evaluation of what your needs will be based on the location to which you will be sent.
Remember..... with the herd your have and the familiarity everyone here has with you, your word, and your tractor work, you shouldn't have a difficult time selling whatever you finally decide to part with.
It should almost be like selling Girl Scout cookies to all the neighbors..........

  • Like 4
  • Excellent 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
RandyLittrell

That C-160 will still be chugging 50 years from now. It has classic good looks, with a bulletproof motor and trans. The 314H is a close second though. 

 

 

 

 

 

Randy

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Shynon

C 160 would be my choice

  • Like 4
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Pollack Pete

I vote for the C160 with the 314 a close second.As others have said...........keep those 2 horses.

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
roadapples

Personally, I'd like to get down to four. The three 160's and the 520 for the 2-stage....:ychain:

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
ClassicTractorProfessor

For me, as far as ease of use, maintenance, and repair, while still being a great worker, the choice is simple go with the C-160. The 314H is close second though, as I have always preferred the Hydro for mowing. I suppose it all depends on what your needs in a tractor will be at your new location. If its going to be mostly mowing and maybe pushing some snow, then I would probably keep the 314H, but if anticipating any ground engaging work, then I would go with the C-160, that big 16HP Kohler paired with the 8-speed transmission is hard to beat. 

 

They are all very nice looking tractors, wish you the best of luck in choosing just one, out of that lineup I think I would have a terrible time picking just one to keep. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
jellyghost

Wow.

I voted for the C-160 too.

When are you going to start listing tractors? I don't have the cash in pocket, but that is some motivation to start saving!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Aldon

Poll is running currently 51% for C160, 23% for 314H, and 14% for GT14/16 resto.

 

I was hoping to make a decision before next weekend and start listing it all Saturday.

 

I was leaning towards selling as a package but not sure many have that kind of slush fund sitting idle for a hobby. 

 

Decisions..decisions......

 

Like a few have mentioned, it would be a lot easier to reduce to 2-3 rather than 1. 

 

Storage at the other end of my relocation ihas the most impact and is driving the decision. I need to further research options which might delay my decision a few more days. 

 

I can say with confidence that the RJ35’s will have to find new homes at this point. 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
19richie66

I voted gt16 due to the fact that I love that tractor and how much work you have in it. You know the hydro is good as is the engine but afterwards I thought about it. My choice would be the C-160 and the 314. When it comes down to overall usability, those two would be it. Hate to see any of them go but sometimes you just have to do what tou have to do.

  • Like 3
  • Excellent 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
953 nut

Aldon, we all will have to make this decision (or our heirs) sooner or later but hate to see it happen. I would keep the GT-16 because it has your fingerprints on every part. You showed it a lot of love and did a wonderful job on the build. 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
whtractors24

314 as many  parts are available and has electronic ignition . Easy steering for the 2 stage for you as well.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
ztnoo
8 hours ago, Aldon said:

I was leaning towards selling as a package but not sure many have that kind of slush fund sitting idle for a hobby.

 

I'd say that's a reasonable assumption and approach.

Someone might lust over one of the RJs for example, and have absolutely zero interest for instance in the GT22-8, or anything else for that matter.

That could be deal breaker for sure.

I think you could maximize your return by selling each of the culls individually.

Of course, it would require more time and communication on your part with prospective buyers, but I believe it would allow you to find the highest bidder and get the biggest dollars for your equipment.

Individual selling of tractors would likely foster more competition for any particular model.....i.e increases your likelihood of a interested potential buyer(s) with cash in hand at a maximized price.

I think the numbers of individuals interested in a one time, buy-it-all-at-once deal would be dramatically lower due to the sheer money involved.

Just my twocents.gif.ae088fe4ddb43f388481ea6c953ac33d.gif

Edited by ztnoo
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • Southern_Secret
      By Southern_Secret
      Wooohooo!! Well after 7 long & hope drifting years iv finally done it I found me a WHEELHORSE! I'm in the south, those of you that don't know (all of you above the mason-dixon line) looking for a garden tractor, well it's like trying to find a grain of salt on the beach. I first had my interest peeked 8ish years ago when we went on vacation in northern TN. While up there, there was a guy who had 2 cub cadets parked in his yard, one with a sickle bar mower and one with a hammer knife mower on the front and I thought that was so cool. Fast forward several month's of digging and reading and I had made my mind up, my tractor had to & was going to be a WHEELHORSE no matter how long it took to find it! The days turned to weeks the weeks to month's and the month's to years......welp.... that's that it's not in my card's, I guess i'll just have to go green. My hunt slowed down to a crawl, still look but pushed to the back burner, better yet put in the far corner of the attic but still hoping that one day I will own a garden tractor (didn't matter what color at this point) although not very hopeful. Then one day I'm on market place and I see an ad for a 314H hmmm bet facebook has tricked me again, then I look at the location and its in my town.....wait just a min..... that's just a half mile up the road from me, so I click the ad. I start reading it "vintage toro mower for sale don't know much about it I think it will run just needs a carb and some wiring" but I cant tell much from the pics but what I can tell is that it has been sitting under a pine tree for a pretty long amount of time. I send the guy a message and set of a time to look at it, the next day when I got off work I make a B line to his house (on the same road I live on, I know right) and to the back yard we go. He tells me that the older guy he bought the hose from traded him so work for the mower and he didnt know much about it, but the PO had put a briggs carb on it and it was bogging down when engaging the pto is what the PO told him. (i will be posting more pics and when I do you will understand this next part better). I'm standing there looking at it as he's telling me this and I lift the hood and he points and tells me "that is the briggs carb he put on there I think if you replace that it will run" what he was pointing at was a huff-n-puff that had been put on to do away with the OEM pump. So by now I'm glowing inside, and I ask him his price he tells me $200 but if i was really interested he would do it for $125, I ask him if I can think about it over the weekend (this was on a friday) he say's thats good with him. I come home and immediately find this place and after digging on here I new right away I was going back and buying that thing monday!
      I head to his house monday after work money in hand, but before I hand him the money he ask me "yall own the NAPA store in the next town over with the tire shop right?" yes sir we do "can yall mount some tires for me?" yes sir we can "if you will mount & balance 4 tires for me ill just trade you out even". I shook his hand and the deal was made, that was at the begging of september and after some looking over the tractor reading on here and waiting on parts, I got it home last week (i had it at my shop at our napa store).
      Sorry for the long post everyone!!



    • BillKC
      By BillKC
      Price reduced to $1,350. Please IM BillKC if you are interested or have questions.
       
      I have an RJ-35 and two RJ-58s for sale that need to go to a good home. Also included is a snowplow, three K91s, and two spare rear wheels w/tires mounted. I mounted a newer engine on the RJ-58 just to push snow and do some light mowing for fun. The RJ-35 runs great and fun to drive around and experience the beginning history of the Wheel Horse lineup. Someone before me started restoring one of them so it is a project. Paint is great but needs put back together. I also have a copy of Straight from the Horse’s Mouth (2000 copyright) that goes with these tractors.
       
      I don't have any way to transport these so Local pickup in Smithville, MO.
       
      Do not want to separate the lot. You can buy them all and sell what you don't want to other collectors.
       
      Thanks,
       
      Bill







    • ebinmaine
      By ebinmaine
      A HUGE thank you to Tony @Docwheelhorse for settin' me up here.
       
      The generosity of some of our members never ceases to amaze me.
       
      This here is another 1974 C160, but with the rare Tecumseh HH/OH160 OHV engine. Made one year only.
       
      It's rough. Very much in need of a full disassembly and restoration.
       
      When it came here it was missing one tie rod and the other was broken off one end.
      Today I popped used tie rods on and Trina used her 867 to drag it from the drive to the shed.
       
      The engine wouldn't move.
      Tin was near chock full of skeletal mouseseses and their house.
      Cleaned that out and the engine spins freely now.
       
      So progress has been made.
       
      It'll be a good long while before we get to this one but I just couldn't turn it down considering the rarity.
       
       




    • Brian33
      By Brian33
      Hello, 
       
      I am hoping someone can help my. I recently acquired a c160 for the engine for another tractor. So I did a motor swap and wanted to see what the hydro was like. I put a plow on it C-160 (which now has a 12hp engine on it). I did a quick test run and everything was good. I drained the fluid and change the filter (Napa 1410 filter and sae 30 transmission fluid as it stated to only use this fluid on the tractor.) everything was working great after the fluid change. I plowed two driveways and the sidewalks near my house... all the sudden the tractor would not go forwards or in reverse. I tried to pick the plow up and nothing... I checked my drive belt it was turning like it should. I started to push the tractor and the rear was engaged so it would not move. Of course I was 400’ from my driveway and the plow was down which made it fun. I put the tractor in forward and started to push it and the thing took off. So I hopped on and took it to the front of the garage. I put it in revers and it cut out again so I pushed it in the garage. Today I went out to check the tow valve. I took it out and cleaned the threads up put it back in and it did not change anything. According to the dipstick I have the proper amount of fluid in it. I did have a drip that I fixed on the cylinder still nothing... does anyone out there have any tips to help me out? I’ve never had a transmission like this only manual transmissions. The model of this transmission is the sundstrand 90-1140.
      Any help would be greatly appreciated.
       
      Brian



    • DennisinTN
      By DennisinTN
      I was given a 314H in trade for some work. Love the tractor but I cannot tell what Sleeve hitch adapter will fit the hydro. Will one for a 314-8 fit. What do I need to attach to the deck lift? I've read hundreds of posts on here and figured this is where to find the experts. Thanks in advance. 
×
×
  • Create New...