ri702bill 13,337 #1 Posted 4 hours ago (edited) BUT... I thought the quoted price was overly excessive and did it myself. The PO of my 2018 V6 Tacoma 4x4 only had the basic Maintainence services done before he traded it in - oil changes, brakes, tires, Inspections - all done on time. However, he neglected all the extra 60K mile $$$ Services - changing all the driveline fluids, flushing the brake system, and replacing the 6 spark plugs. I performed the driveline fluid changes and flushed the brake system this summer - I replaced the plugs & PCV Valve this week. Changing the plugs is very labor intensive - doing so gets you 90% of the brackets & hoses out of the way to do the PCV Valve.... I prefer to use OEM parts where I can & specially if they are within a few bucks of chain store parts of dubious origin.... So I went to my local Toyota Dealer to buy the PCV Valve & asked the Service Writer the cost to change the plugs. Without hesitation he said $1085! He then told me it was a 3-1/2 hour job - so I did feel better that it took me 4. I caught the OEM Denso plugs on sale - and along with the OE PCV, I'm into it for under $140. Even at $250 for the parts, the Labor cost seemed high... I will farm a job like this out IF it is priced "Reasonably" - as i put a value on my time too. And I understand they have expenses too.... My point to this is why does the cost of changing 6 plugs rate up there with the cost of a Mortgage or Loan payment?? Edited 3 hours ago by ri702bill 2 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ebinmaine 81,198 #2 Posted 3 hours ago Labor rates have increased dramatically of late. As with anything else there are multiple factors involved. Up here the dealers are getting 125 to 150 or more per hour and still struggling to keep budget. We're lucky to have a great selection of reasonably priced smaller shops that can still charge much less. 1 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Handy Don 17,702 #3 Posted 3 hours ago Got to chatting with the owner of my preferred auto service shop about costs. He pointed out that homeowners like it when the politicians want to tax business properties more than homes, but that extra dough has to come from somewhere! During my years as a technology consultant pitching and delivering the company’s services, I aimed for hourly rates three times the direct cost of the on-site labor. I was privy to enough of the financials to see that marketing, HR and payroll, healthcare, office space, technology, and keeping talent on the bench for short periods between engagements left relatively modest profits to the owners 4 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,337 #4 Posted 3 hours ago All this is why you must ask for and scrub the service records on a used vehicle prior to purchase. A smile & a handshake at the sale does not define the "True Cost of Ownership" down the road. 29 minutes ago, ebinmaine said: a great selection of reasonably priced smaller shops that can still charge much less. A new wrinkle to that.... Small shops, like my Son being an independent Automotive Locksmith. need to be on an OEM's approved list in order to secure a 24 hour License to access Factory Software - with a per Diem charge up front.... unlimited access for those 24 hours, not a minute more. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
adsm08 5,246 #5 Posted 2 hours ago (edited) 1 hour ago, ri702bill said: My point to this is why does the cost of changing 6 plugs rate up there with the cost of a Mortgage or Loan payment?? Because your dealership is charging nearly $240 an hour for labor. Do you live in a high COLA area? Is it in a larger city where the technicians are possibly unionized? I will say, that while I understand the price of auto repairs is higher than it used to be, I get really frustrated with this attitude towards auto repairs. I see lots of complaining to the tune of "the price for this repair on my car is ridiculous" or "the shops are just out to rip people off" but I basically never see that same attitude leveled against other professional trades like electricians, plumbers, or HVAC guys. And we have to know a everything those guys know and more, but I actually make less than a lot of those people. Edited 2 hours ago by adsm08 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
rmaynard 17,646 #6 Posted 2 hours ago I have a 2014 Tacoma. After the initial "free" oil service, I have always changed my oil myself. When I asked the service writer to have someone show me how to check and fill the driveline fluids, he said that you can't check them on your own. It was then that I found a good independent shop. I now have 106,000 miles and have never changed the transmission oil. My independent shop says it's not needed yet. Still running the original plugs too. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Wayne0 1,661 #7 Posted 2 hours ago (edited) 1 hour ago, ri702bill said: BUT... I thought the quoted price was overly excessive and did it myself. The PO of my 2018 V6 Tacoma 4x4 only had the basic Maintainence services done before he traded it in - oil changes, brakes, tires, Inspections - all done on time. However, he neglected all the extra 60K mile $$$ Services - changing all the driveline fluids, flushing the brake system, and replacing the 6 spark plugs. I performed the driveline fluid changes and flushed the brake system this summer - I replaced the plugs & PCV Valve this week. Changing the plugs is very labor intensive - doing so gets you 90% of the brackets & hoses out of the way to do the PCV Valve.... I prefer to use OEM parts where I can & specially if they are within a few bucks of chain store parts of dubious origin.... So I went to my local Toyota Dealer to buy the PCV Valve & asked the Service Writer the cost to change the plugs. Without hesitation he said $1085! He then told me it was a 3-1/2 hour job - so I did feel better that it took me 4. I caught the OEM Denso plugs on sale - and along with the OE PCV, I'm into it for under $140. Even at $250 for the parts, the Labor cost seemed high... I will farm a job like this out IF it is priced "Reasonably" - as i put a value on my time too. And I understand they have expenses too.... My point to this is why does the cost of changing 6 plugs rate up there with the cost of a Mortgage or Loan payment?? I have a 2016 TRD Off Road. Did you pull the intake for the plugs? It can be done without pulling it, but there is a process and only takes a couple hours.https://www.tacomaworld.com/forums/3rd-gen-tacomas-2016-2023.186/ Edited 2 hours ago by Wayne0 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,337 #8 Posted 2 hours ago (edited) 31 minutes ago, adsm08 said: Do you live in a high COLA area? Is it in a larger city where the technicians are possibly unionized? Nope & not sure... I fully agree that demographics come into play with pricing.The ultra high volume dealerships on the "Auto Mile" - a main thoroughfare outside of Boston loaded with New Car dealers - sell oodles of cars at a modest profit looking to make it up later on trade-in value or Service. Case in point - A Ford Dealer in that area offered a "10 year, 100,000 mile Powertrain Warranty* " on all new private use vehicles from them... Sounds good until the fine print reveals that *ALL recommended service MUST be performed on time, by them or the warranty is voided. So most folks go along a year or two beyond the Factory warranty and trade in the car to start over as the Maintainence costs are climbing.. I was looking for a new Focus years back and noticed this Dealership had 4 or 5X the number of "Certified Used" cars for sale.... Folks tired or the back end upkeep cost???? Hmmmmm..... Edited 2 hours ago by ri702bill Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,337 #9 Posted 1 hour ago 15 minutes ago, rmaynard said: I have a 2014 Tacoma. After the initial "free" oil service, I have always changed my oil myself. When I asked the service writer to have someone show me how to check and fill the driveline fluids, he said that you can't check them on your own. It was then that I found a good independent shop. I now have 106,000 miles and have never changed the transmission oil. My independent shop says it's not needed yet. Still running the original plugs too. Mine is the rare 6 speed Manual Transmission. Toyota uses magnetic drian plugs on the Transfer Case, Manual Transmission & Differentials. all can be cheaked for fill level & drained individually. The T-case & Transmission were fine, both differentials were low & the front one the fluid was overdue to be changed. They DO make a nice product though... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,337 #10 Posted 1 hour ago (edited) 39 minutes ago, Wayne0 said: I have a 2016 TRD Off Road. Did you pull the intake for the plugs? It can be done without pulling it, but there is a process and only takes a couple hours Although the Haynes repair manual says to remove the intake - i too found a great step-by-step Video where you do NOT have to remove the upper half of the intake plenum to do the 3 plugs on the driver's side. Small hands & a lot of patience - it can be done.The guy in the video listed all the tools necessary to do all 6. You do need to undo the upper half of the Air Cleaner box and tube up to the throttle body and rotate it up out of the way to do the passenger side plugs. Super easy that side. Edited 1 hour ago by ri702bill Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
adsm08 5,246 #11 Posted 53 minutes ago (edited) 1 hour ago, ri702bill said: Case in point - A Ford Dealer in that area offered a "10 year, 100,000 mile Powertrain Warranty* " on all new private use vehicles from them... Yeah, my employer has a similarly deceptive practice. They offer a "lifetime engine warranty" on all used cars they sell. Fine print says that maximum liability is $5000 and once you hit $5001 they won't pay a dime, even if you pay the difference. Most engines are $10K just in parts. So on a $10K engine replacement they won't split it with you $4999/5001, the whole job is <$5000 or they pay $0. Edited 52 minutes ago by adsm08 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,337 #12 Posted 34 minutes ago 14 minutes ago, adsm08 said: deceptive practice??? YES - but. remember, you did not pay anything for the "dandling carrot" up front - so don't complain when it falls thru.... Legal, yes - unethical, definitely. I would not be surprized if the "fine print" was done in disappearing ink!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ed Kennell 47,846 #13 Posted 26 minutes ago 1 hour ago, ri702bill said: "Certified Used" I see this sign at every lot. Do you get a notarized document that guarantees the car has been used? 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,337 #14 Posted 18 minutes ago That referrs to a vehicle that has a complete paper trail from day 1 up to the present showing that ALL recommended services were done on time at either their facility or another Factory Authorized one... oil changes, cabin air filter replacement, wiper blades, State Inspections, tire rotations, and ALL recall warranty work, etc. done. Most Fleet vehicles don't have records that clean & complete... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites