953 nut 70,439 #1 Posted yesterday at 12:04 PM November 20, 1923, the U.S. Patent Office grants Patent No. 1,475,074 to 46-year-old inventor and newspaperman Garrett Morgan for his three-position traffic signal. Though Morgan’s was not the first traffic signal (that one had been installed in London in 1868), it was an important innovation nonetheless: By having a third position besides just “Stop” and “Go,” it regulated crossing vehicles more safely than earlier signals had. 4 1 3 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Achto 32,939 #2 Posted yesterday at 12:46 PM The new solution for intersections has made everything much less confusing. 4 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,324 #3 Posted yesterday at 01:36 PM (edited) Here in West Warwick, we only have one - so far. It is all single file traffic; wait to pop into a safe? opening, circle around to exit at the road of your choice, and depart. Neighboring Warwick now has 5 Rotaries (roundabouts, what ever you want to call them). Those have double lanes to carry a higher volume of traffic, and are meant to merge 5 or more roads. The grand theory is that you enter the outside lane & stay there if you are taking the next exit or the one after that... go to the inside for exits 3, 4 & 5, then attempt to get back into the outer outer lane to depart.... Ha! A true Rhode Islander will NOT circle around if they miss the opportunity to exit - it could explain the emergenge of Auto Body Shops immediately nearby.... To traverse Rt 117 all the way thru Warwick, you need to deal with all 5 of these. Happy, happy, joy, joy!! Holiday traffic only makes it worse. Edited yesterday at 01:37 PM by ri702bill 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
953 nut 70,439 #4 Posted yesterday at 01:38 PM Though the RED goes on top of a standard traffic light don't tell that to the Irish/American residents of Syracuse NY. The stop light at the intersection of Tompkins Street and Milton Avenue in Syracuse, New York's Tipperary Hill neighborhood is famous as the only upside-down traffic signal in the United States, with green on top and red on the bottom. Why It's Upside Down 1920s Protests: When a standard red-over-green signal was installed in the 1920s, residents in the historically Irish neighborhood viewed having red (associated with British rule) above green (associated with Ireland) as an insult. The "Stone Throwers": Local Irish-American youths—nicknamed the "Stone Throwers"—repeatedly broke the light with stones. The Flip: The city eventually flipped the signal so green sat above red, a layout that has remained as a local landmark ever since. In the late 1920s my uncle got a ticket for running a red light at this intersection and went to court with an affidavit from his ophthalmologist stating he was color blind, case dismissed. In the early 1930s the standard GREEN lens on traffic lights was changed to a blueish green and the RED to an orange red to aid colorblind drivers. 3 3 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
ri702bill 13,324 #5 Posted yesterday at 06:24 PM 4 hours ago, 953 nut said: In the late 1920s my uncle got a ticket for running a red light at this intersection and went to court with an affidavit from his ophthalmologist stating he was color blind, case dismissed. In RI, the Eye Doctor would have expected a kickback for beating the ticket & avoiding penalty points on the Car Insurance..... 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
stevasaurus 23,887 #6 Posted 23 hours ago I did not know about rotories until my 1st encounter. It was winter of 1970, I was in the Navy and driving my 1960 Belaire Chevy to my 1sr tour of duty in Winter Harbor Maine. I believe it was along Rt# 95 in that little out break of New Hampshire, that reaches the Atlantic. It was night and all of a sudden, I found myself if a circle at maybe 45 mph ! I think I went around 3 times before I figured out what happened and how to get out. Some yahoos in Illinois now in 2026 think rotories are the answer to our traffic issues. I know of one here in town that they built and have since destroyed because the cities Fire Engines could not navigate the circle. DAHHH!!! Not learning from their follies, rotories have been built at intersections on State Routes that you run into at 50 mph. I am not sure how many people have either died or have been scared out of their wits entering something they have no idea what just happened. I would much rather have a Stop Light at an intersection where you may have to guess which way you want to procede. End of rant!! Thanks. Achto's picture sums it all up for. Here is the real issue...if you have driven around Chicago, you will understand what I mean here. Driving the Inter-States is dangerous. You are taking your life in your hands if you are in the wrong lane and unsure of where you should be. The people that know where they are going are annoyed at out of towner's that all of a sudden arn't where they want to be. I was sitting in an 8 hour traffic jam on the way to the Big Show in Penn maybe 2018 ?? I was riding with my wife that needed facilities after a few hours sitting still on INTERSTATE #94. I'm surprised we went back to the Big Show after that. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SylvanLakeWH 32,841 #7 Posted 23 hours ago Couldn't disagree more with the negative sentiment about correctly designed roundabouts. They are excellent for both moving traffic and reducing severe crashes. Proven time and again. Simply put - Traffic signals cause crashes that are far more severe than roundabouts. Michigan has had excellent results with them, provided they are designed correctly for the traffic volume. 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
stevasaurus 23,887 #8 Posted 23 hours ago Sorry Sylvan...my experience is driving into them without knowing how they work, or when they show up in places where they weren't before. Once I know they are there, it's OK...except when Fire Trucks can't navigate the circle. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Handy Don 17,694 #9 Posted 23 hours ago (edited) I’ll be a bit contrary here, so skip this post if you wish! 😁 I like roundabouts. I’ve traversed many, many of them in the UK, Ireland (yes, driving on the left), and "on the continent.” They have been proven to move vehicles through intersections more quickly by numerous studies, especially in low to moderate traffic situations, which I appreciate. Once learned, they lessen crashes and the severity of crashes (glancing blows instead of T-bones). I’ve yet to encounter a roundabout in the US (Mass. has quite a few) that did not have adequate signage, including speed limit warnings where appropriate. There are three important points to make: - ALL of driving is learned behavior. Our ability comes from initial instruction, experience, and from adaptation based on previously learned behaviors. - Because roundabouts are not (yet) common in many areas of the USA, many drivers' inexperience with them colors their reactions. Many members here learned to drive before interstates and parking structures were available yet, somehow, managed to get the hang of them without disaster. - The above image is from a roundabout in France where the rules of the road (amazingly) give the right of way to a vehicle entering the roundabout. That’s how these mega-jams happen. In contrast, throughout the US, the vehicle already in the roundabout has the right of way (consistent with the other rule of un-signed merges/intersections where the vehicle to the left has the right of way) so unless the exit road is blocked, the circle will drain. Edited 20 hours ago by Handy Don 1 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SylvanLakeWH 32,841 #10 Posted 22 hours ago 21 minutes ago, stevasaurus said: except when Fire Trucks can't navigate the circle. Properly designed, there are no fire apparatus limitations... 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
953 nut 70,439 #11 Posted 21 hours ago 1 hour ago, stevasaurus said: Once I know they are there, it's OK...except when Fire Trucks can't navigate the circle We have a wood floor manufacturer in Franklin, NC and they receive several tractor trailer loads of rough-cut oak and walnut every day. The first roundabout built in Franklin was near that factory and there was no other way around to enter the plant's storage yard. The roundabout had standard curbing about six inches high around a rather small center island. That concrete curbing lasted about two days, it was no match for an 80,000 pound 18 wheeler. Three of the other roundabouts in town already had the center islands constructed so they had to be torn out and made much lower with only a one inch curb. 54 minutes ago, Handy Don said: I’ve yet to encounter a roundabout in the US Come on down to Franklin, NC (population 4,500) we have seven of them. Early one morning with hardly any traffic I was approaching one of the roundabouts and a car was stopped at the entrance. I stopped behind him and after a few seconds he turned on his LEFT turn signal and hung a left headed for the closest side street to the left. Nobody else was on the roundabout so he managed to make it safely onto the street he was headed for. I just laughed and went on my way. Growing up near Syracuse NY, we had the infamous Carrier Circle, hold on for dear life. It connected the New York Thruway, The road that went to a GE small appliance plant, The road that went to the Carrier Air-conditioning plant, a couple of large foundries and Bristol-Myers Pharmaceuticals. Two other roads that led to Motels, Restaurants and large trucking depots also cam off of the circle. The geniuses who engineered the traffic circle seemed content to have it be a one lane circle which was totally inadequate. Then they came up with an even worse solution, lets make it three lanes wide. When I took Driver's Education in high school the instructor made each of us enter the circle, merge left to the center lane then blend with traffic to the right and exit where we had entered. Fortunately this was not during rush hour and if you were able to accomplish this you got an "A", didn't matter how many times you went around as long as you came off at the correct exit. If left the circle at the wrong exit you got a do-over for a "B+". The steering wheel of that '61 Chevy Biscayne had the fingerprints of a few students permanently imbedded in it. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Handy Don 17,694 #12 Posted 20 hours ago 51 minutes ago, 953 nut said: When I took Driver's Education in high school the instructor made each of us enter the circle, merge left to the center lane then blend with traffic to the right and exit where we had entered. Gutsy instructor, but what a terrific lesson! 54 minutes ago, 953 nut said: Three of the other roundabouts in town already had the center islands constructed so they had to be torn out and made much lower with only a one inch curb. Clearly, not only drivers have to learn about roundabouts--there are roadway designers that need educating too! 56 minutes ago, 953 nut said: turned on his LEFT turn signal and hung a left headed for the closest side street to the left. Same person who backs up on the shoulder of the highway after cruising past their exit? 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
953 nut 70,439 #13 Posted 20 hours ago 2 minutes ago, Handy Don said: Gutsy instructor, but what a terrific lesson! He said sooner or later we would end up out there on our own and he wanted to know he had properly prepared us for the experiance. 1 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
c-series don 12,681 #14 Posted 8 hours ago Speaking as I believe the only one on this forum that drives a fire truck that is a tractor trailer tanker, there’s a traffic circle in the neighboring fire district that is entirely too small in diameter. Pretty much every tractor trailer that goes through it has to drag the trailer wheels up on the inside curb. When it was first installed it had nice flowers and bushes on the inside of the circle. However they did not last long as they were constantly getting run over. Now it’s mostly concrete on the inside. Apparently the engineers who designed it missed class the day they discussed tractor trailer turning radius’s?! 6 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Beap52 2,528 #15 Posted 7 hours ago Diverging diamond interchanges are becoming popular in Missouri. I think they work great and smooth traffic once folks understand how they work On the other hand, we have "J Turns." I don't care for them. You enter traffic onto a 4 lane highway only to quickly merge to the left lane, make a U turn then crossing two lanes of traffic to enter an outer lane (being aware of traffic turning onto the outer lane to exit the highway then merge back into traffic again. I prefer to stop, watch traffic both directions on 4 lane highway, then cross the first two lanes and either proceed straightway across or turn left. If I'm on the 4 lane highway, find myself entering a "J Turn" area cautiously because you never know when the fellow entering the highway is going to do his darnedest to get to the U turn. roundabouts, I can take or leave them. They are quicker because you don't have to stop entering the roundabout. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dan 312-8 661 #16 Posted 7 hours ago 16 minutes ago, Beap52 said: I think they work great and smooth traffic once folks understand how they work. We have several in my area, and yes people need to get use to them. I see more deer in the headlight expressions when a percentage of the population attempt to navigate these. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SylvanLakeWH 32,841 #17 Posted 6 hours ago 1 hour ago, c-series don said: Speaking as I believe the only one on this forum that drives a fire truck that is a tractor trailer tanker, there’s a traffic circle in the neighboring fire district that is entirely too small in diameter. Pretty much every tractor trailer that goes through it has to drag the trailer wheels up on the inside curb. When it was first installed it had nice flowers and bushes on the inside of the circle. However they did not last long as they were constantly getting run over. Now it’s mostly concrete on the inside. Apparently the engineers who designed it missed class the day they discussed tractor trailer turning radius’s?! That's precisely why I noted "properly designed" in my previous post. There are numerous designs that accommodate trucks through mountable curbs and concrete "skip pads" for trucks. We have them in place all over Michigan and they work great. 41 years as a planner taught me one thing - have police and fire folks as part of all our site plan, park, road and utility planning processes. They "know" things the engineers and we planners only read about... 3 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
wh500special 2,469 #18 Posted 6 hours ago This forum is largely populated by a bunch of grumpy old men (me included) so it’s not a surprise that something new or different - like a traffic circle - is met with apprehension. In the 15 or so years that I’ve lived in my current town the planners have been continuously updating intersections with roundabouts. It’s taken a while for their use to become second nature, but now that they’re commonplace and we’ve had practice it’s become pretty clear they can work and by my observation they have streamlined traffic flow. They seem to have been implemented most successfully on intersections that had previously been four-way stops without stoplights and where increasing traffic would have eventually required installing a signal. Our town has been growing and there are some sportsy-sports attractions that bring in a lot of traffic - and revenue - on weekends. So managing traffic has been a mounting priority. my cousin’s husband is a big shot civil engineer with a firm who does much of the design and engineering for state traffic protects in IL, IN, OK, and MO. A few years ago when I delivered an unsolicited , close-minded opposition monologue against roundabouts at a family gathering he countered with an analysis of the cost savings that comes from maintaining a roundabout versus an intersection with a stoplight. The 5+ year maintenance savings were almost unbelievable, so he ended up emailing me some data to back it up. In a world where we pretend to want our government to make a long-term decision that saves money, this is generally a subject where the math can actually work out. And still we have a hard time adopting. Back to our town…(no, not Grover’s Corners). We had two businesses in town that were semi-truck intensive. Both dairies running milk tankers and enclosed trailers back and forth all the time. The main road that services both of them ended up with roundabouts at each end of town. The one on the west side is pretty tight and the trailer wheels ride up on the curb in the center. The one on the east side is much larger and even a 53-footer with a sleeper truck can roll through without any effort. By no coincidence, trucks headed for the tight circle go right by a school, downtown development, and a couple parks. All places with lots of kids and pedestrian traffic. The tight circle was such a pain in the neck for the truck drivers that eventually they avoided it and took the other path even though it was out of the way if they were headed west. I’m quite certain the traffic engineers knew about tractor trailer turn radii. Clearly this was a case of deliberate planning to channel truck traffic to the (marked) preferred path. Evidently they (trucks) weren’t generally obeying the truck route and enforcement wasn’t working. An occasional truck still passes through the tight circle as evidenced by the tire marks up on the island, but it’s not like it was. yes, there are outlier cases where a tight circle would suck - like in a fire emergency - but as long as it’s navigable there’s a workaround. I’m not completely sold on roundabouts, but they have their place. For vehicle traffic they seem to work great, but when pedestrian traffic is mixed in I think it’s still a little hairy. Pedestrians cross the intersecting roads just outboard of circle and i think it’s not generally a location where a driver who is exiting the circle is expecting to see someone on foot. Diverging diamond interchanges are becoming a thing around here too. The first time I encountered onemy thoughts channeled Dorothy Parker ( “what fresh…?”), but I can see they do reduce the number of potential spots where vehicles intersect each other. That initial time through where you’re suddenly on the opposite side of the road is a bit disconcerting though. Anyway… Steve 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Handy Don 17,694 #19 Posted 5 hours ago 14 minutes ago, wh500special said: Diverging diamond interchanges Reading the first sentence in your post, I remembered the moment I realized that my long-held plan to be a grumpy old guy was dashed. Someone reminded me that at my age, I should know better. Dang, I used to say that to my young children! I’ve read about diamond interchanges but haven’t yet traversed one. Something to look forward to! 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
953 nut 70,439 #20 Posted 5 hours ago 15 minutes ago, wh500special said: Diverging diamond interchanges are becoming a thing around here too. The first time I encountered onemy thoughts channeled Dorothy Parker ( “what fresh…?”), but I can see they do reduce the number of potential spots where vehicles intersect each other. That initial time through where you’re suddenly on the opposite side of the road is a bit disconcerting though. Asheville, NC has one of those and it is wonderful, though it did scare the heck out of me the first time I used it.No one has to sit while a left turn lane backs up traffic behind it and it is by far the safest way to move a high volume of traffic at an extremely busy intersection. Stuart, FL ha one of the most famous intersections in the US, Confusion Corner. In the mid 1970s engineering students from MIT spent several weeks doing traffic counts, studying the interaction of drivers going through the seven streets and railroad tracks that all intersect at confusion corner, their conclusion was that it is virtually impossible to pass that much traffic through such a maze of streets that make up this sevin way intersection where no one has the right of way; but it happens every day, 24-7-365, The students came up with several proposal that would involve removing existing businesses, take up several acres of land and were estimated to allow about 75% of the traffic count that occurs on a daily basis. Now another study is beginning. The likelihood is that this study will come to the same conclusions as the one done over fifty years ago but this time they will spend several hundred million dollars to make the situation no better and less charming. City of Stuart secured a $1.866 million grant through the FY 2025–2026 Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) Rail Crossing Elimination Grant Program to fund planning and engineering studies for safety and traffic improvements at Confusion Corner 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites